Insert or full-frame window replacement?

Find out which parts of the old assembly each proposal keeps. Scope and the condition of the parts that remain are key to this decision.

Trace which pieces stay with an insert

An insert is fitted within an existing frame that remains in the opening. Ask the installer to show which old frame, joints and trim will stay. Ask how they will check that those parts are suitable to retain. If you see staining, a change in how the sash fits or damage around the sill, flag it before settling on a scope. Compare the expected visible glass area once the new unit is inside the old frame.

Find out what a full-frame option opens up

A full-frame replacement removes the old window frame. Ask which surrounding layers and trim the proposal includes, what is visible after removal and what still needs separate work. Ask what will happen if damaged materials turn up, including who documents the condition and how changes are approved. Compare any effects on the interior finish and exterior wall. Request a section drawing showing the finished frame position for each proposal.

Make a scope list for each proposal

Use three columns for stays, removed and newly supplied. Ask the installer to fill in any parts you cannot identify. Use a separate list for each opening condition.

BC Housing’s consumer guide to window and door replacement

Put your questions in a project brief

Include the room, the opening and any details you want checked.

Start a window project